The Best Super Bowl Cross-Sports Prop Bets For 2024

Super Bowl cross-sports prop bets are an engaging way to wager on events from other sports along with the Super Bowl in the same bet. In fact, NFL betting sites are getting more creative with their available cross-sport Super Bowl prop bets each year.

We are surveying the Super Bowl cross-sport prop bets market and making our best predictions across a variety of sports. If you want even more weird Super Bowl props, check out our national anthem and coin toss bets. Head below to find our best Super Bowl cross-sports prop bets to wager on for Super Bowl 58.

Super Bowl Cross-Sports Prop Bets

The following cross-sport Super Bowl prop bets are courtesy of BetOnline:

We have carefully hand-picked the best Super Bowl cross-sports prop bets from sports betting sites.  Most of which could be considered weird Super Bowl prop bets, these cross-sport bets cover a variety of sporting events.

The largest favorite from our bets is the highest-scoring college basketball team to score more points on February 10 than 49ers’ running back Christian McCaffrey’s rushing yards total.

Where To Bet On Cross-Sport Super Bowl Prop Bets?

BetOnline is your ultimate online destination for betting on Super Bowl cross-sports prop bets. With new prop bets being added daily, BetOnline will have a plethora of unique cross-sport bets for Super Bowl 58.

Regardless of the sport, and even wagers that include the LVPD and politics betting, the Super Bowl cross-sport bets at BetOnline are unmatched. Currently, BetOnline has roughly 60 cross-sport Super Bowl prop bets on the board, more than any of the other Super Bowl betting sites.

Make a deposit to instantly get a 50% match bonus of up to $1,000. For double the bonus, deposit with a cryptocurrency to grab the full 100% match bonus. Additionally, BetOnline has numerous Super Bowl betting promotions including risk-free wagers and prop bet contests.

Ready to play at BetOnline?

Visit BetOnline

Total Nick Bosa Sacks vs. Total WM Phoenix Open Hole-in Ones

The Waste Management Phoenix Open is a golf tournament typically held on the same weekend as the Super Bowl. The tournament usually features a quality field for one of the best fan experiences on the PGA Tour.

Will a player at the WM Phoenix Open hit a hole-in-one? If it does occur, then this prop bet has a chance of at least pushing. For a win, you’ll likely need the Chiefs to prevent Bosa from recording a sack.

The odds of hitting a hole-in-one are difficult enough, never mind twice in one tournament. According to the PGA of America, the odds of a Tour player hitting a hole-in-one is 3,000 to one¹.

The odds come down considerably if you consider all the attempts during a four-round event. Nevertheless, hitting an ace off the tee is a difficult feat for any golfer. Bosa is coming off a two-sack performance in the NFC Conference Championship.

Following 15.5 and 18.5 sacks the last two years, Bosa regressed to 10.5 sacks this season². That said, we expect to see Bosa greatly involved in the pass rush for the 49ers. As one of our top Super Bowl 58 prop bets, we like Bosa’s chances of having more sacks than hole-in-one shots at the WM Phoenix Open.

Christian McCaffrey Longest Reception vs. Total Rounds of Teofimo Lopez/Jamaine Ortiz

On Thursday, February 8, Teofimo Lopez will defend his WBO junior welterweight titles versus Jamaine Ortiz. The fight is scheduled for 12 rounds at Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas, Nevada, the home of Super Bowl 58.

Regardless of whether this fight goes to the judge’s scorecards, McCaffrey should win this bet. McCaffrey has been an asset to the 49ers as a pass-catcher out of the backfield. He is used in multiple different formations on the field, which makes it difficult for defenses to defend him properly.

The 27-year-old Stanford product had 564 yards receiving on 8.4 yards per reception in the regular season. He’s notched at least 12 yards per reception in six of his previous eight games. McCaffrey collected a 28-yard reception against the Lions in the NFC Championship.

There is a strong chance that McCaffrey’s longest reception will surpass Lopez and Ortiz’s total rounds.

Highest Scoring NCAAB Team On Feb. 10 vs. Christian McCaffrey Total Rushing Yards

Saturday, February 10, is set for a full day of college basketball action. It’s a packed card from the afternoon, to late into the evening hours.

Will the highest-scoring team on February 10 exceed McCaffrey’s rushing yardage? According to the Super Bowl cross-sport odds, yes, overwhelmingly at –400 odds.

The highest-scoring team will likely score in the high 90s to just over 100 points. Anything beyond that would be unusual.  In other words, this is essentially a bet on whether McCaffrey will eclipse 100 yards on the ground.

In the regular season, he gained over 100 yards rushing in seven games. McCaffrey has recorded 90 and 98 yards in two postseason games. Additionally, since November 23, the dynamic runner has averaged 102.75 yards rushing per contest³.

The Chiefs haven’t been terrific against the running backs this season. They’ve yielded an average of 113.2 yards rushing for 17^th in the NFL⁴.

At +300 odds, you must consider backing McCaffrey to win this cross-sport prop bet. The cross-sport Super Bowl odds for this wager are well out of touch at the best football betting sites.

Brock Purdy Longest Rush vs. Total Round 4 WM Phoenix Open Eagles

Round 4 of the WM Phoenix Open should produce at least a few eagles. TPC Scottsdale isn’t a particularly difficult course for Tour players to navigate. With that in mind, eagles shouldn’t be incredibly rare.

That said, even if there are four eagles on Sunday, Brock Purdy should have the upper hand for this cross-sport prop bet. Purdy has increasingly been using his mobility to pick up first downs. If Purdy doesn’t use his legs against the Lions, the 49ers might be sitting at home right now.

The 24-year-old ran for 48 yards on 9.6 yards per attempt in the NFC Championship. He’s averaged 5.6 yards per attempt in the NFL Playoffs, and 3.7 yards per attempt in the regular season⁵. With a matchup against an aggressive Chiefs’ pass rush on tap, Purdy will have to roll out of the pocket and run.

Look for a six or seven-yard rush to be Purdy’s longest. That should put him well ahead of the WM Phoenix Open’s eagles converted in the final round in Arizona.

Jayson Tatum/Jaylen Brown Total Points vs. Total Points in Super Bowl 58

The Over/Under for Super Bowl 58 is listed at 47.5 points. The Super Bowl 58 odds suggest that the total points in the game should be roughly 47 points. We like the defenses to do their part on both sides of the ball, however.

For our Super Bowl 58 predictions, we like a 24-21 final score in Las Vegas. With that in mind, the Boston Celtics’ Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown should combine for more than 25 points. They should get over 50 points without too many issues against the Miami Heat on Super Bowl Sunday.

In 2023-24, Tatum is averaging roughly 27 points per game. On a good day, Tatum can surge over 30 points. Last season, he averaged just over 30 points per game⁶.

Brown is capable of eclipsing 30 points, too, but realistically, he should score 25 to 22 points against the Heat. This season, the Celtics’ shooting guard is averaging 22.3 points per game on 49.1 percent shooting⁷.

Let’s give Tatum and Brown around 55 points. That should give Tatum and Brown the win over the total points scored in Super Bowl 58.

Deebo Samuel Total Targets vs. Vancouver Canucks Total Goals

On Super Bowl Sunday, the Vancouver Canucks take on the Washington Capitals at Capital One Arena. The Canucks have been on fire this season, with the best record in the NHL. They visit a mediocre Capitals’ squad looking to stay afloat in the Metropolitan Division.

The Canucks have averaged 3.8 goals per game for the second-best mark in the NHL. Only the Colorado Avalanche have scored more this season. Meanwhile, the Capitals are 13^th, with an average of 3.02 goals against per contest⁸.

Expect the Canucks to score three or four goals on the road. A 3-2 or 4-2 game looks about right. Samuel is coming off an eight-reception, 89-yard performance versus the Lions in the NFC Championship.

Despite being injured, Samuel was targeted nine times. With two weeks to rest, Samuel should be close to full health for Super Bowl 58. Over Samuel’s last nine starts, he’s averaged 6.6 receptions⁹.

Samuel is likely to see at least six targets in Super Bowl 58. That will likely do it over the Canucks’ goals on February 11.

Oscar De La Hoya Professional Wins (39) vs. Patrick Mahomes Total Pass Attempts

Will Mahomes have more than 39 pass attempts? If the Chiefs’ QB does, he will surpass Oscar De La Hoya’s professional win record of 39 wins.

The Chiefs reinvented themselves to get to Super Bowl 58. They aren’t in Las Vegas because of Mahomes passing the ball 40 times a game. The running game and defense were the major catalysts.

That said, Mahomes will have to pass the ball to counter an aggressive run defense. The 49ers are one of the top teams in the NFL against the run. Mahomes has averaged 37.3 passing attempts per game¹⁰.

In the AFC Championship, he completed 30 passes on 39 attempts. He might need just a little more pass attempts to counter the 49ers’ ability to disrupt the run. At +115, we are backing Mahomes to surpass De La Hoya’s 39 wins.

Domantas Sabonis Total Assists vs. Travis Kelce Total Receptions

Sacramento Kings’ Domantas Sabonis has devolved into one of the most multi-dimensional players in the NBA. He is a valuable asset to the Kings, who run much of the offense around where he is on the floor.

Sabonis is a facilitator with the ball in his hands. The 6-foot-10 native of Lithuania has averaged eight assists per game. Getting into double-digit assists hasn’t been a problem for Sabonis.

As of February 4, he’s notched a minimum of 10 assists in nine games since January 1, 2024, and in six of his previous 10 games. On January 14, Sabonis recorded a career-high 15 assists against the Milwaukee Bucks¹¹.

Expect Travis Kelce to have a solid game, but this is likely a seven-reception game for Taylor Swift’s guy. Side with Sabonis to have more assists than Kelce’s receptions in Super Bowl 58.