As the competition heats up on the American Idol stage, online bookmakers have released American Idol odds for Season 23! The prices will jump up and down until the very end, and I will be there to take full advantage of any good betting opportunity.
In this article, I explore the latest winner odds, analyze the top contenders, and make my 2025 American Idol predictions after each episode.
American Idol Season 23 Odds After the Latest Episode
We will be adding our updated American Idol odds, analysis, and predictions after each episode here, so you will continue to have fresh information as the season progresses!
Here are the latest winner odds, courtesy of BetOnline:
| CONTESTANT | ODDS |
|---|---|
| Slater Nalley | +300 |
| Mattie Pruitt | +400 |
| Canaan James Hill | +650 |
| Drew Ryn | +800 |
| Filo | +900 |
| Thunderstorm Artis | +950 |
| Jamal Roberts | +1200 |
| Baylee Littrell | +1200 |
| Gabby Samone | +2500 |
| Grayson Torrence | +2500 |
As of the Top 20 episode, 18-year-old Slater Nalley (+300) is the current betting favorite to win American Idol Season 23. As a +300 favorite, Slater has a 25% implied probability to win the American Idol title this season.
Following him closely, Mattie Pruitt (+400) has the next likeliest chance with a 20% implied probability. Per the latest American Idol betting odds at entertainment betting sites, Slater and Mattie are in tight contention to win the top prize.
That said, there isn’t one top singer who has emerged as the clear favorite to win American Idol in 2025. After Mattie, gospel singer Canaan James Hill rounds out the top 3 at +650. He holds a 13.3% implied chance, staying within striking distance, but Slater and Mattie hold the advantage.
You can find up-to-date American Idol 23 odds at BetOnline by navigating to Sports > Entertainment > American Idol.
American Idol Season 23 Top Favorites
The American Idol Season 23 winner odds reveal three main contenders have emerged in the Top 20. Although the odds do not always point to the winner, they are a great barometer for how things will play out.
Let’s dive into the latest prices and my complete analysis of the top contenders:
Slater Nalley (+300)
The American Idol betting markets tip in favor of Slater as the competition rolls into the Top 20. Slater is an 18-year-old high school student from Atlanta who is rising high on American Idol.
The young southern rock singer-songwriter immediately grabbed the attention of the judges in his audition. Praise from the judges has continued throughout the competition. He’s doing it all at the tender age of 18 and is gaining momentum with the season progressing.
In the latest episode, Slater made it to the Top 20 with his rousing rendition of the Allman Brothers Band’s “Soulshine”. He has a deep voice that is made for easy listening and the radio. Slater should have success whether he wins American Idol or not.
Additionally, Slater has proven to be a versatile singer who can reach the high notes or tone it down across a variety of genres. He focuses on southern rock but can seemingly transition into country or whatever the challenge is for the week!
There’s tough competition for Slater, but he should be one of the final contestants standing.
Mattie Pruitt (+400)
Slater’s main rival heading into the Top 20 is Mattie, according to the latest American Idol 23 odds. The native of Eagleville, Tennessee, is only 15 years old, but one of the top favorites to win American Idol!
Despite being even younger than Slater, Mattie is the one singer who could elevate her game to top him. Described as a soul country singer, Mattie is probably the most memorable vocally on the season of American Idol. There are hints of Stevie Nicks or Janis Joplin in her performances that make her a powerhouse.
She has a raspy voice that is instantly recognizable once you’ve heard her sing two or three times. That kind of memorable voice in a contest of singers that often have a difficult time standing out can go far on American Idol. Although she is at her best on country songs, the 15-year-old has proven she can nail other genres, including pop.
In addition to raspy elements, Mattie is capable of reaching the high notes to put her over the top. Like Abi Carter last year, all it can take is one huge power performance to give her the edge. Will Moseley was a heavy favorite until Abi went big to showcase the power in her voice.
I can envision the same kind of results for Mattie, who hasn’t even reached her full potential on the show yet. With this in mind, Mattie has to be on your shortlist of 2025 American Idol picks to win!
Canaan James Hill (+650)
Fresh off “Songs of Faith” week on American Idol, Canaan was in his wheelhouse on stage. The gospel singer received a lay-up from producers and easily made it through to the Top 20.
Gospel music is where Canaan shines, but if you take everything away and simply listen to his voice, he’s one of the best on Season 23 of American Idol. The control, structure, and strength of singing ability is more than present.
However, is Canaan as versatile as the other top singers this season? Maybe not, but he’s mature beyond his years. I don’t think you are going to find a person who would believe Canaan is 17 years old after listening to him sing with so much soul!
I have expectations for Canaan beyond American Idol. He is reminiscent of Ruben Studdard from Season 2 who won the competition over Clay Aiken. I don’t know if gospel music resonates with the audience as much as it did in 2003.
However, Canaan is well on his way to signing a record deal for a gospel album. Additionally, he will have a devoted fan base of voters at home, so he should make it to at least the Top 5!
American Idol 2025 Predictions and Betting Pick
Last year, I nailed my American Idol prediction by betting on Abi to win the singing contest. I foresee Mattie following a similar trajectory. Abi wasn’t perfect in the early rounds of American Idol Season 22, but she got her song selection right and soared later on.
Look for Mattie to do the same and tap into songs that best showcases her arsenal on stage. Right now, Mattie’s song selection is fine, but I want to see the 15-year-old dig into her raspy roots and shine. As I noted, Stevie Nicks comes to mind, so Fleetwood Mac would work perfectly for her.
Additionally, Mattie can work on her stage presence to separate herself from the competition. In any event, she has the foundation to build on and has the most upside on the show this year. Instantly recognizable voices are tough to find on singing competitions, and she has it.
In summary, Mattie is my top bet to win American Idol Season 23!
Where to Bet on American Idol Season 23?
American Idol betting sites have a host of options for bettors in 2025! For our top recommendation, we suggest checking BetOnline to bet on American Idol. The site offers updated betting odds for American Idol Season 23 on a weekly basis.
Bettors can wager on their favorites to American Idol all the way up to the American Idol finale at BetOnline. Deposit at BetOnline to claim $250 in Free Bets with no rollover requirement. The offer also includes 100 in Free Spins!
Welcome Bonus
50% up to $250
- Sports betting, casino, and poker
- Over 400 games available
You must be logged in to comment. Don't have an account? Sign up today.